Advertisement
Is there a larger gated white community, Radically Exclusive, by using financial incentives to keep people out? 47,000 people is a tough number to beat. Maybe for every whitie, they should bus in some other ethnic groups for free.
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:04 PMthere are many gated basicily non-white communities all over our country. they are not living the american dream and may love a chance to get a little clean dust for a week or so. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:16 PMi thought the theme of next year was white people? Isn't that the american dream?
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:17 PMCrap. I went there with a black girl one year. No one ever said anything like "oh my god, you're black" because it would just be dumb. We're all the same color by Tuesday anyway. -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:22 PMHahaaahhhaaaa!
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:52 PMShooter thanks you for your act of charity for the poor black woman that couldn't pay her own way. Very honorable of you to pay her way and bus her in in your vehicle.
I think it's sad that BMORG sets ticket prices against the financial abilities of non-whites. I also think that it is sad that they are all so poor. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:09 PMall things considered, I think that the scholarship program puts the event within the financial abilities of most anyone.
at least anyone with determination. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:09 PMI beg to differ.
If you live on the East Coast, even if your ticket is only $95, just the cost of getting there can be prohibitive, not to mention food and supplies. And, obviously, that's not the fault of the BMORG. But even if you don't camp with a theme camp, even if you somehow manage to hitchhike across the country (and good luck with that if you're a small, solo female like myself), it's a lot of money spent and a lot of money lost from not working for that time, and most people I know would not be able to swing it. I only did by scrimping and working my ass off all summer, and next year, when I will be without the option of a scholarship ticket, there's probably no way I will be able to attend. And I'm not exactly in the dirt-poor category, just the working student category.
If ticket prices rise, the financial aspect definitely has the potential to turn the event into an alterna-resort for the well-off and bored built on the backs of thousands of (really awesome) volunteers. I mean, more than in some small ways it already is. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:22 PMSo, why doesn't someone on the east coast start something over there? -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:29 PM//So, why doesn't someone on the east coast start something over there?//
they have. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:40 PM//So, why doesn't someone on the east coast start something over there?//
they have. "
Oh good. Then people who can't afford the plane ticket, or who would rather not burn all that fossil fuel getting to a party can still have somewhere to go. That's nice.
Rachel, why don't you go to this thing closer to home? Is it just that it's to small, or "not the same" or what?
Stacycat, what is this thing? Does it last a week? I’m assuming you mean a regional, or is it something else? -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 2:28 PM//Stacycat, what is this thing? Does it last a week? I’m assuming you mean a regional, or is it something else?//
depends on what part of the east coast... there is PDF in delaware (regional event, 2x per year) plus firefly (new england regional) and transformus (southeast regional).
there are many, many other non camping events that happen all year round, in several cities on the east coast. people can find out about them by joining their regions email list. instructions are on burningman.com
i am a huge fan of the regional network and i have traveled to many, out of curiosity... that being said, none of them 'replace' burning man for me. they arent even a good substitute. but, theyre fun!
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:27 PM//I beg to differ.
If you live on the East Coast,//
ironically, all but one of the african americans i know who go to burning man are in NYC. its not $$ keeping the non-whites at bay.
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:34 PM"and next year, when I will be without the option of a scholarship ticket, "
Why not? I've read the application and I thought there was a "please give me a discount so I can come because BM means a lot to me" bent to it. I'm sure those things are in essay form instead of multiple choice so that people who have extenuating circumstances like yours, who would enhance the city somehow, can be heard. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 2:23 PM//Why not?//
from what i remember, you cant get a reduced price ticket 2 years in a row.
-
-
-
-
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 3:51 PMPaynie, I never noticed that you were black. If I had I would have said something. ; )
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:08 PMReally? Gated? Where are these gated non-white neighborhoods? -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:45 PM<<Where are these gated non-white neighborhoods >>
They're called prisons. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 2:05 PM<<Where are these gated non-white neighborhoods >>
<<They're called prisons.>
And projects. Habe you guys ever taken the 19 bus from SoMA all the way to the Navy Yard? What an eye opener and I am a native (Hispanic) woman.
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 11:19 AMBRC went from being a mix of survivalists art freaks and counterculture warriors,
to where it is today.
the absolute opposite.
it is, essentially, a white persons fantasy.
nobody else gets it. the music, the emphasis,
it's become so damn geeky, so honky,
i couldn't go anymore. no year number 8 for me.
so, reading articles like this give me greater faith in
the scene surrounding brc.
long live the whiners.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:26 PM
It's far from safe to assume that the predominance of whites at BRC is an indicator of others not being able to afford entrance.
The most exclusive thing about BRC is not (just) $$$, but culture.
Many ethnic groups come from a different cultural/historical legacy (read: more conservative values) than the average Burner. Also consider that for members of many ethnic groups which have attained economic and social inclusion more recently, running off from all the luxuries/comfort one has worked so hard for seems daft.
The whiteness of BRC is more an indictment of society at large and the lines we allow to divide us outside (and inside for some) BRC. Changing that is only partially economic, but probably more about introduction to the Burning Man culture, pioneering spirit, self-reliance, etc.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 10:47 PMperhaps the most well thought of response in this thread. thanx Michael
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:36 PMHow dare you!
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:41 PMWow, Shooter, you are one racist fuck.
To have such a low opinion of not-white ethnic groups that you actually think that 'they' can't afford a ticket?
Bussing 'them' in. That's funny. Just imagine the throngs of angry, empty beer bottle throwing Burners lining the entrance, yelling "Poverty stricken not-white person, GO HOME!" -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:58 PMshooter,
come over to england and chill out with me and mine
you need it and will have a high time
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 2:59 PMHave you seen the Malcolm in the Middle at Burning Man? It has much better demographics than the real event.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 11:08 AMit's true. malcom cares.
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:02 PM
BRC is statistically "white" by self-selection, not by the intent of the organizers or by any other restriction. There are "people of color" (to use a mostly PC term) who go, even if it is not as many as those who value diversity would like. BRC is also about 2/3 male, also by self-selection, but that does not make it a male-only event.
It is an interesting question about whether BRC itself is a community. I do wish that it was more of a community than just an event. I have some amazing experiences of community there, but I also see a lot of very selfish acts, so I'll just have to stay undecided.
The financial barriers to entering BRC are pretty small, and even a little work makes them smaller. The assumption that all people of color are poor is borderline racist.
A potential example of a larger "gated white community" is Yosemite National Park. It is larger in average weekly attendance (70k vs. 50k for BRC) and area (1189 square miles vs. about 4 for BRC), and the difference is much larger for the peak weekly attendance. It is gated, statistically rather white (unofficial measurement by eyeball), and may be just as much a community as BRC. And the feds are responsible for both areas.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:44 PMBurners = well fed white people
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:44 PMPeople always forgets us Asians. I saw a lot of us out there.
Everything is NOT black and white you know! ; ) -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:51 PMYes, I admit the opening comments of this thread are rather myopic towards Asian-Americans and the one African-American that Paynie brought to the event.
More than the overwhelming WHITENESS of BRC, the fact is that they have a radar system to keep out people that don't have money. The wall around the city is built to hold out those who do not pay. And the hundreds of dollars is just on cost, once you get into burning man. . .
The Largest Gated Bourgeoisie Community might be a better name. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:54 PMwhats you're problem shooter?
sorry dpw pissed you off but hey there are many perils in the world huh? -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 6:52 PMI don't have a problem, Simon. And not sure what you are talking about DPW. I just posted a topic for discussion on a public discussion board.
I didn't see any mention of DPW in that post.
I am disappointed in Larry Harvey, but then again, he is just another white corporate guy trying to make a buck. ha ha ha. -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:01 PMYou may not have a problem, Shooter, but you clearly have an agenda to find fault with Burningman in any way you can. It's like an obsession with you. Even a complete stranger like me can see it. It's a driving force to your life, at least your life when you're online, on here.
I saw your clip of the protest outside BM offices, and I agree that if all you contend is true it is a sad state indeed how paid workers are treated by BMorg. But it goes much further with you, it's festering inside you, and unhealthy for you and ultimately the person it is hurting is you. I get it, Burning man was so much better in the old days, I get it, you should've seen Bali when I used to go to it decades ago. Or Ko Samui before there was an airport. Everything changes. Get over it, take some responsibility for yourself, and heal.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:51 PMGee, )(, I have this agenda called not drinking the Koolaid. Other people, including most news agencies do this day. It's hardly a driving force of my life. It's something that I do in my spare time. Now the war in Iraq and Afghanistan, where I have spent the past few years, that is festering inside me.
www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:07 PM -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:32 PMGreat podcast!
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 12:25 PMthat podcast is hilarious and great!
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 9:01 AMWhy I don't go to BMan
by Jessica the black woman.
See to me camping is Motel 6
I was a RAGING Hippy in the 70's and all my belongings fit nicely in one back pack. I camped, couch surfed, communed, hitchhiked and walked about from coast to coast for many years. I pay a mortgage now and see really no need to camp.
My husband wants to go to BMan and I so encourge him every year to hook up with some friends and burn on. He loves playing with fire...married me after all.
So (for me) it's not the event, it's not that there are few people of color there.....it's....well....I'm in my luxury phase now.
and I digg it y'alls
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:07 PMYeah! And look at me, after 3 days - black as the night y'all.
It only took me 8 months to make the money so I could buy a ticket to go.
So there.
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:54 PMYou people are sick!
(GAWD-bless every single oneofya!)
LMAO
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 3:59 PMHuh. And here I was appreciating how diverse it seemed to me out there in comparison to other communities I've been a part of. I wonder what the statistics would work out to be if they were figured. I imagine there were some communities that were seriously underrepresented. For example, I didn't see a whole lot of Latinos. Although I can't always tell which minority someone is from. I think I might have brought one myself. It seems kind of moot to ask, since we're all burners
Then again, communities are built on social circles - who looks/talks/acts like you. I don't expect an exceptionally high percentage of minorities to want to look/act/dress like burners. Then again, I don't expect a high percentage of WASPs to either.
There's also the question of who *thinks* they can make it out there. I've noticed a huge perception gap amongst people I've talked to. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 4:08 PM
all the more reason to leave expectations behind - expectations of who you might ask to go, as well as who you expect to see there. (Or at least do the best you can to leave expectations behind)
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 4:16 PMEvery time someone brings up BM with one of my black friends, they respond with something like "When I can spend it in an air conditioned RV with a dish watching football all week, I'll think about it." Then someone brings up the dust and they''re back out.
I, on the other hand, am caucasian, but as an hispanic am also considered "a person of color" (check out the post BM profile pic). I took a few days off work before BM, a week off for BM, and another week off post BM. I spent a couple of thousand dollars for the privilege on top of that but ya, that discounted ticket for being in fire conclave made all the difference in the world. Thanks for looking out for poor little ol' me. You rock Shooter!
Will this bus of yours pick me up here in Los Angeles? What about my bike? Can I bring my bike? Or do us underprivileged types get free bikes too? This is such a good idea. I think you should buy us new tents, too. The one I have now is all dusty and shit. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 4:20 PM
hey shooter, should I step up as a POC, or remain cloaked in the whiteness of the Internets??
stereotyping's not fair, why make Burning Man *MORE* complicated - the theme sucks, now it's not diverse, the food's not right, no RV's - this is all stuff you can FIX in the DEFAULT WORLD or work to make better, eh? Hey, maybe the DEFAULT WORLD actually influences Burning Man, that red-headed stepchild...
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 4:35 PM<Is there a larger gated white community, Radically Exclusive, by using financial incentives to keep people out?>
Nonsense. Many of the people I know go to BMan for free. How? They're involved in building the damned thing. So, there's no excuse that a person couldn't "afford" to go. Heck, all anybody needs to do is save $20 a month. That means going one day a week without buying a latte. That's it.
As for black people not going, many if not most black folks come from families where they spent a lot of years trying to get *indoors* and don't want to go back outside. "Roughing it" is for rich white people. Most black folks I've met want no part of "roughing it." They're trying to get away from that experience.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 4:40 PM> Many ethnic groups come from a different cultural/historical legacy (read: more conservative values) than the average Burner. Also consider that for members of many ethnic groups which have attained economic and social inclusion more recently, running off from all the luxuries/comfort one has worked so hard for seems daft.
i also heard that many african american people are (understandably) uncomfortable seing a burning human-figure with arms stretched - from a distance, that really ressemble the burning of a cross. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:50 PMmaybe it's that I am coming from NYC - but we keep bringing people out who happen to be of color...things ARE less segregated out here culturally in any case...
the black folks that do come that I know - are completely diverse in their response to the dust factor....some rent RVs some rough it.... no one seems to complain about the man who burns...
I think its a matter of inviting and being helpful like you are with any newbie....talk it up!
Maybe folks just need to diversify their lives in general - its not JUST as burningman issue...
But all this "black folks won't like it because ....." is crap.
Plenty will and many do.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:55 PMDavid, that is not true at all. Very few people are accepted as volunteers. It is rather exclusive, and while you are working for free, while Larry Harvey is making his largest profits ever, you have to pay rent and pay your way to the playa, your cellphone bill, your car insurance. A substantial portion of Larry's profits come at the expenses the people who are allowed to work for free. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 8:03 PMlest any of us forget that Burning Man is FUN.... yeh, you know, fun?
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 12:58 PM<It is rather exclusive, and while you are working for free, while Larry Harvey is making his largest profits ever [....] >
BMan is hardly "exclusive". As I said, for a mere $25 a month, or a few lattes a month, anybody can afford a ticket. As for the other costs, you borrow camping equipment. Surely, not all your friends are going to BMan, so if you don't have equipment you can borrow. Assuming you have friends, of course.
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 5:05 PMa burner friend who is african american, when asked by friends and family why she doesnt date more people her race, responded: "black people dont like to go where i go!"
another friend's first year was 90 or 91 (i forget) is also african american. he knows (as do i) plenty of people, of many races, who can afford to go but dont. its more racist, in my rarely if ever humble opinion, to assume people of race cant go only because they cant afford it. maybe they dont wanna go. there are times when my white ass doesnt wanna go, either!
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 7:46 PMShooter
What makes you think that minorities would need to ride a special bus into BRC?
What makes you think that minorities can't afford to go?
Do you really think that Bman LLC gives a shit who is paying the bills?
Now!! let's be honest here. If the event was 99.99% ( how do I put this diplomatically?) "ethnic", how many of you/us/shooter would be interested??!!
How many people are on your friends list that are members of an ethnically excluded group?
~Wendell~ -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 8:49 PMmy impression is that most of us, especially shooter, are lamenting the lack of burner color... -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 9:13 PMWhy are we lamenting the lack of people who do not want to be there?
And who exactly are these folks?
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 9:18 PMI don't really know what to think about this topic, we have always
had colored folks from New York in our camp, Black and Brown, and
I usually have neighbors camps where several members are Asian or
Islanders. Considering how white the neighborhood I live in is, I see
a much larger percentage of minorities from where I am while I am at
Burning Man than I see in my everyday life from day to day.
This was definately augmented this year by the three illegal mexican
workers I smuggled in to push my artcar around in order to offset my
carbon footprint by not using the gasoline engine under the hood.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 9:52 PMYeah, The Green Penis draws in some color. ha ha ha. I wonder how many space aliens attend the event.
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 5:48 PM<i>This was definately augmented this year by the three illegal mexican
workers I smuggled in to push my artcar around in order to offset my
carbon footprint by not using the gasoline engine under the hood. </i>
literally lol'd.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:09 PM<my impression is that most of us, especially shooter, are lamenting the lack of burner color...>
My impression is that Shooter is a cynical troll. If he or anybody else *really* cared, they'd simply bring their non-white friends to BMan with them. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:16 PMbut that would be too easy! -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:52 PMyup...
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 9:34 PMShooter = TROLL. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 9:37 PM -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 9:45 PMLoved eet!!!
Everyone, he answers ALL your questions.
And I would rather listen to Johnny Cash than techno any day!
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 9:49 PMfucking brilliant. i love it.
-
Words from The Black Guy
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:54 PMYes, it's me. The Black Guy at Burning Man. I did the Podcast you guys were talking about. By the way, that was the old version. I just updated it.
web.mac.com/tonyedwards/...C95545C0.html
Most of what I would want to say here, I already said in the podcast.
I appreciate the fact that you guys are having this discussion. It's one I have had with many Burners over my six years going there. Basically, here's my spin...
The lack of Black people (and people of color, for the most part) has nothing to do with financial issues. Hell, for many young Brothers, a ticket to BM is, what, a couple pair of Nikes? If you are a poor White person, you're probably not going to Burning Man, either. That's why God invented reality television.
It's not about White people not wanting us there. Some don't, most don't care. But if we didn't go some where where we think that some White people might not want us, we wouldn't go anywhere.
It's all about appeal. Burning Man just doesn't appeal to most Black people. Were not the only ones. Evangelicals probably don't dig Burning Man. People who can't stand being dirty are not going to go. I'm not expecting to see George Bush there ever, which is part of the reason that I go. And I don't ever see myself visting, Dollywood, Stone Mountain or 90% of Alabama. It's nothing personal. Just not my cup of playa dust.
I think that some people want to see Black people at Burning Man because it makes them not feel like they are the elistists that they are. And tha's cool too.
Just as long as they are all hot Black chicks...
-
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 11:28 PM
thanks OhTony!
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 8:50 AM"because it makes them not feel like they are the elistists that they are"
HAHAHAHHA - Purrfecto!
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 9:19 AMTony -
That was a brilliant podcast. I laughed hard at your insight and your "hippie clan meeting" analogy.
later
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 10:06 AM// Just as long as they are all hot Black chicks... //
Well... some of us want to see more hot black dudes on the playa....
and white ones,
and brown ones,
and yellow ones,
and green ones,
and red ones,
and orange ones,
and blue ones,
and purple ones toooooo !!!! -
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 2:10 PMPart of me is purple... -
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 3:52 PMI'm yellow on the outside...and white on the inside...
black on the outside...white on the inside...
green eggs on easy over and ham all around...
-
-
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:53 PM"But if we didn't go some where where we think that some White people might not want us, we wouldn't go anywhere. "
Haahaaha dead on. THANK YOU.
-
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:59 PM
damn correct. go have fun, do YOUR life, whereever...
-
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 4:45 PMWhat about hot caramel mocha women?
I'm getting a kick out of this thread!
It got me thinking about my camp this year (I have to admit I am pretty fucking color blind). One Pakistani woman, one half Mexican/half Chinese woman, one Armenian man, and one fabulous Mexican (me) and about 12 white people by Sat. We brought the g*d damned rainbow coalition! Haha. Yes, there are a ton of white people there but it is only representative of the demographic across the country. Not all cities can be as deliciously diverse as my hometown (SF). But what keeps people, either of color or white, away from the generally inhospitable playa environment isn't money, folks.
My fiirst year I had to go 100% solo since all of my (majority white) friends I asked to accompany me balked at the a) cost, b) heat, c) dust d) dirty naked hippie factor. Some people, regardless of color or socio-economic status, simply aren't ready for the playa or BMan. Out of the 70+ people that work in my law firm, about 80% are white yet the only two people that have attended are a Chinese woman and myself. Truth is, you have to be somewhat tolerant of the outdoors to go to BM and a majority of people of color don't get out into the backcountry, go hiking on the weekend, or even own the equipment to enable them to do so. For me, it was that my parent's had no clue there was fun to be had amongst the trees so I wasn't ever exposed to it until college. I volunteer with two organizations that do exactly that, get kids of color out into the back country...sometimes for their first time. So no, it doesn't have to do with money, like Tony said it is lack of appeal maybe due to the lack of exposure/opportunity within the minority communities.
As for feeling underrepresented, I honestly don't notice. I echo Tony's well-versed sentiments.
Don't feel guilty. In the words of David Best, "It's not your fault."
Now the ancestors...that's a whole 'nother story.
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 8:45 AMfuckin intelligent! thanx for speakin out.
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 12:30 PMtony your fucking hilarious!
-
Re: Words from The Black Guy
Tue, September 25, 2007 - 1:04 AMOh, Tony,
Your words are fabulous and your voice is so tony and so's your brain.
Thanks for sprinkling some humor through a prism of intelligence on a topic
that had gotten lost in translation. Love the podcast.
My first-time experience at Burning Man (older white woman is diversity, too!) showed
me it was a gathering of like-minded, like-spirited people. All the other adjectives are
pretty irrelevant in terms of finding a common denominator.
Psychologically, what's all this projection of what Burning Man "should be"?
How about checking the reality of what it is, rather than what it isn't?
Just sharing some thoughts, boys and girls.
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:00 PMWow, I am a now a TROLL for speaking about provable demographics -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:01 PM -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:47 PMGive Shooter a break folks. He raises some, though not all, of the legitimate questions for Bmorg to ponder. He's thoughtful and daring. whether you like it or not, he's a force to reckon with and he's here to stay. Besides, he's cool.
now Shooter do I get my lolipop? -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:52 PMthats just creepy.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 9:55 AMthat podcast was really funny thanks tony! :)
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:52 PMNo, you're a troll because you're a troll. I guess it all depends on what you are out to prove.
How is it somehow my fault that the demographics are predominantly white? How is it that you think Larry is sitting around making sure them colored people don't get in. How many non-whites have you invited? Do you tell them that they are too poor if they say no?
Why aren't you complaining that Gerlach doesn't have enough black people? Should bus some in and make them live there.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:55 PMITYM: Largest Gated White Owned Community in the US, which doesn't require the registration of Sex Offenders. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:59 PMThough I here they are starting to crack down on psychotic types who like to brandish very large knives in order to compensate for their incredibly small penises.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:19 AMLarry Harvey is a shitbag, mostly, so I don't have any bad feelings raising issues that question his motives. And yes, Cowboyangel, you get a lolipop, of course. This is just a message board, and I have learned a few things on this thread, which was the point of making it. I am not looking for votes, or friends, just what people think.
And as for being a Troll, that is a compliment. At least I am not a suicidal koolaid drinking Jim Jones follower. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 11:01 AM//And as for being a Troll, that is a compliment. At least I am not a suicidal koolaid drinking Jim Jones follower.//
youre kind of the equivalent tho, on Opposite Day at least.
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 12:35 PMgod forbid shooter brings up something that ruffles the feathers of this tribe. Isn't that what kinda makes things work.
We do things one way, then someone asks some questions and things change....
I find on message boards that people skim through a lot of the messages and just look for the quick response that will edge people to respond in a hateful manner.
Remember people... Even tho there is text and nice picture behind it all is a human trying to speak their mind.
Let them and don't bash them but question them. Things change from topics like these and the paul addis thing. I personally enjoy burningman however it saddens me what is going with it right now and people like shooter and others are finally speaking their mind but everyone is hating on them for it.
Step back, breathe, see what they say and comment in a non hateful way. Don't look for that keyword that will make you post, instead post because you want to contribute! -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 12:42 PM//Even tho there is text and nice picture behind it all is a human trying to speak their mind. //
questioning shooter gets you nowhere, all he does is respond with the same anti harvey dogma. why bother? its nothing new. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:00 PMI know better than to question Shooter, or to try to convince him of anything Borg or BM. He's formed his opinions in the crucible of his DPW former life.
Maybe it's the DPW pedigree that makes me still respect him, even if I don't agree with him. He is just about the only consistent anti-Borger I have any respect for.
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 4:05 PM//questioning shooter gets you nowhere, all he does is respond with the same anti harvey dogma. why bother? its nothing new.//
hrm, just moments after posting this, the user "Free Paul Addis" randomly started making nasty comments about 'white people' on photos i posted to this tribe a long, long time ago (2005 or earlier). he must have had to seach for them. did i piss ya off, hon? tsk. so very, very sorry. please, please dont hurt me anymore, daddy!
haha! jerk.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:05 PM
>
Step back, breathe, see what they say and comment in a non hateful way.
Shut up - hippie!
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 5:33 AM
>And as for being a Troll, that is a compliment. At least I am not a suicidal kool-aid drinking Jim Jones follower.
Anymore than you're a 'journalist.' -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 10:40 AMYou are so sweet Badger. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 1:04 PMHmmmm..
There were a lot of "minorities" there this year as I noticed more than last and I suppose the year before and so on and so forth. Every day I ran into someone else of "color" or saw someone riding around on the playa, hanging out, at camps etc. I suppose it could be that I'm more tuned in to notice other blacks because I am black, and I am the minority in a majority so I do tend to notice other minorities in settings where we are the minority. Truth be told though, it's never bothered me. It doesn't bother me. I never thought oh snap, there's not that many other blacks here I'm irritated, I can't go OR I have to make sure more people of color are there. I suppose if I felt that I wanted more of a representation I'd rally up my other friends (who vary in race) and persuade them to come. They'd love it as much as I do. But then again why should I have to?
I figure if people want to go to BM people will go to BM. It has nothing to do with color, money, feeling excluded because gasp more of one race goes more than any other race, or anything else you've spoken about, it all has to do with what you're into. Period.
I happen to be a fire dancer so I love being around other fire dancers. That's why I go. That's why I love it. That's why I'll continue to go. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 5:07 PMBut Aingeal, I think the point of this thread was to complain about Burning Man and to make people feel bad about enjoying themselves there!
Substance was not really a priority. Thanks for taking the wind out of its sails :) -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 8:19 PMdang! my bad. that's what i get for not reading through the whole thing. i'll know better for next time ;-)
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:29 AMJust a side note, but I think some of you may not understand that "people of color" is not the same as "colored" people. The former is the preferred current term; the latter is what used to be used on signs on drinking fountains in the south.
You don' t have to use "people of color" but don't be surprised if black people take offense at being called "colored" and if Hispanics, and members of other ethnic minorities do, too.
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:35 PMWhy are you assuming that people of other ethic groups can't pay their own way? Do you think all nonwhite people are financially insolvent and incapable of even bussing themselves?
Typical white arrogance. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:54 PMWatch out, he's going to play the "I'm not white." card.
-
-
By the way, am I the only Black person responding to this post?
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 10:58 PMI just got in and haven't had time to read them all.
-
Maid Marian claims, that Burning Man "totally mixed" NOT!
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 11:14 PMBurning Man, no matter how you slice it is NOT ethnically diverse. It could do better.
And when folks post crap like this: bm.tribe.net/thread/1a22...215cff6fb974 it makes it a little more understandable why.
Word from the black burners on tribe: blakfriday.tribe.net/thread/...cccd993b
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 11:29 PMDude, BRC has nothing on Utah.
I was thinking about Oh Tony's brilliant Podcast and his thoughts about the absence of hip hop on the playa. BRC Freestyle camp laid down some super sick hip hop in my neighborhood. It was a pleasure to hang with them and listen to their music. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 11:31 PMI meant BRC has nothing on Utah in the way of a radical racial imbalance.
-
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 18, 2007 - 11:47 PMAbout 1 out of 10 of your guy's friends should be black if your going to complain about this. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 12:11 AMRight on! And if you have 2 or 3 Black friends, you better shut up too. The rule is "about 1 out of 10", okay? -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 1:46 AMMELUNGEON POWER -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 10:28 AMFuck yeah, Melungeons! Anyone who can count to 24 on their fingers and toes cant be wrong!
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 8:55 AMUtah
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 9:00 AMShooter, your assertion is basically true. I don't think it's intended though, as somebody else pointed out, it's self selection. Black people could go in larger numbers if as individuals they made the choice to go. Let's not forget how many of the people in BRC are jobless artists, or hippie stoner kids.
That said, I remember my first year on the third or fourth day I saw a black woman ride by on a bicycle and I thought "Wow, I just realized I haven't seen a black person in four days... weird." -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 9:02 AMP.S. "Let's not forget how many of the people in BRC are jobless artists, or hippie stoner kids. " was meant as a counter argument to the criticism that we are (As Fox News said) all white teenagers with fat trust funds.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 10:04 AMIn my time at BM over ten years, I've camped with and hung out with people from just about every ethnic group, gender preference, religious affiliation, political bent, economic level and age group from all over the world imaginable. The idea that BM is only a homogeneous white, middle class event is ridiculous. People who don't see the diversity at BM probably don't because of the "radical self-expression" of true participation that tends to put so much of that diversity in the background. Yeah, there are a lots of white middle class types but they tend to stand out because they're more likely to be the ones wearing default world clothes camped in big RVs and walking around gawking at everyone else but they're hardly the true BM demographic. More likely they're just easier to link together by appearance and behavior as a falsely dominant demographic. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 10:24 AMyeah I know its mostly white at Bman, but does that make it a racist community? I think not! Um, HELLO? Its not everyones fault that its mostly white, thats just the way the numbers roll. Sorry its not some Noahs Ark of color and race in the world.....thats just the way it is....Nobodys trying to exclude different races of people out there. COME ON NOW
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 10:26 AMIf I would of just read OhTony's post I wouldnt of felt compelled to make mine.
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 12:41 PMShooter.
I define a TROLL as someone who relentlessly pushes their narrow/myopic agenda due to an exagerated chip on their shoulder. A chip so unwieldly that they can't think straight in regards to that topic.
This is you man.
but don't get me wrong. I've been lurking here for close to two years, and I've enjoyed alot of your posts and I find you to be quite intelligent and thoughtful (for the most part) and humorous. However, in regards to your issues with Larry Harvey and Burning Man in general......you are ACTING like a TROLL.
I realize that sticking it to Larry H and the rest is a pet project for you, but man it's really tiresome.
blackfly. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 2:01 PMFew people of any race find the idea of busting your balls for 7 days in extreme conditions anything akin to a 'vacation'...
perhaps underlying protestantism is our real problem...
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 3:09 PM"I define a TROLL as someone who relentlessly pushes their narrow/myopic agenda due to an exagerated chip on their shoulder. A chip so unwieldly that they can't think straight in regards to that topic.
This is you man. "
I dunno. I've always thought of Shooter as more of an ex-girlfriend who got dumped. Always bad mouthing the ex. Some of what she says may be true (she's in a position to know a lot if inside dirt), but she's always negative, and thats always tiresome.
After a while, you start to think, "If your ex was such an asshole, what's wrong with you, that you put up with him for so long?"
But I don' t think of him as a troll, and I hope he finds a new boyfriend who makes him forget all about Larry. -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 3:46 PMShit! No wonder most of my friends are white people. Fuckin Burners!
Can't we all just get along? -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 5:26 PMWOW, are some of you sniffing glue?
As a halfrican, I love brc and have gone for nine years. I hear all kinds of music out there ( yes hip hop ) and will dance to most of it, ( not the trance crap, I cant move the hips to it, must be a black thing) and I have always met and enjoy meeting a variety of people that are all diverse, in a variety of ways, not just "color". I find that the race thing gets old.
but, this could be turned into a large scale art progect, paint the citizens colored. I have always wanted to be red. set up a variety of stations and pick your color. problem solved.
~ in dust we trust ~
-
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Wed, September 19, 2007 - 5:35 PMcan I be blue? I like blue. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 10:00 AMWhen I first mentioned BM to my sister, the first thing she asked me was if this event was for white people who had lost their culture. I responded to her by saying that yes, some of them had, and some of them are creating a new culture for themselves, because they had lost their old tribal culture. It is my opinion (and only my opinion) that many white people have latched onto BM as a new culture, being that they lost much of their old culture from Europe, whether from time, political pressure, or racially motivated pressure (such as many Irish and Italians now being considered 'white'.)
My own culture is under such pressure as well. For one, I'm not fluent in Spanish like my father is, but then again, he and his classmates were hit by the teacher every time they spoke Spanish, so he raised me English only. Just for the record, his mother's family has been in New Mexico for at least a few hundred years, and his father's grandfather came directly from Spain, so we've been here longer than many "American" families. (I'm a native Californian.)
However, that pressure has not erased our culture (as in the case of the government sanctioned erasing of Cherokee culture, which still managed to survive somewhat.) This is due to several points - New Mexico is still a Spanish speaking state, always has been, and the culture stays strong in that state; a constant new influx of people of Mexican and other "Latin" descents into the U.S., and the slow acceptance of the "American" public that yes, maybe "Latin" people are pretty cool (thank you Ricky Martin and Jennifer Lopez.) And we can dance.
With such a strong cultural influence (I cannot speak for other cultures), for us to seek out and adopt yet another culture is not a strong pull for us. However, being part of one culture, and having only one way of viewing the world is myopic. Some will argue that the U.S has it's own culture, which it does. Just view footage of people getting sprayed with hoses in the south in the 1960's, look at some pictures of "whites only" signs over bathrooms, and look at advertisements for cars, washing machines, and see those happy families, all of whom happen to be white in said advertisements. If you argue that the U.S. has a culture all it's own, it can be seen in our news, and our advertising throughout the decades. The true culture of the fledgling U.S. was a society of mixed cultures, Dutch, English, etc., who had different ways, different languages, but a common goal (granted, slavery existed, but not all of the founding fathers truly believed that institution would last.) That has been lost to paranoia, exclusion, and finger pointing, and xenophobia.
The culture of BM offers an alternative to this, one of acceptance, music, and experiences. In cultures that exist outside of "white" America within the U.S. itself, we have acceptance (to a point), music, shared experiences, and food, yes food. Mmmmm. However, some of us that are considered minorities (up until I was a teenager, I had to check "other" on the racial box) find that even our own culture is lacking something, and we seek to expand our knowledge of other cultures. I find this the common link with whites. There are those who seek to understand for a deeper understanding of humanity (those who are in a culture day in and day out, and make lifelong bonds with people from other cultures), and those who seek to understand only on the surface, simply for the novelty of it (cool, let's get drunk in Bali!)
In finding BM, I found a culture outside of my own Mexican-American heritage that promoted community first, something I had not seen before in white America. However, there were things that I found in the BM community that I had not seen in my own culture. For one, there was the acceptance of being different, having different ideas, and *gasp* it's okay to be an artist!
That being said, I don't think BM is radically exclusive to minorities, I simply think that most minorities have no interest in BM, because they already have a culture, and it serves them just fine, thank you very much. For whites who have lost their culture, BM fills that hole, and therefore in my opinion, whites seek BM out more fervently than minorities with a culture. For those of us who are considered minorities, and for those things we think are lacking in our own culture, we will seek out beyond our own culture. Don't worry too much about finding us, we will find you. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 10:14 AM
Bravo!! Very eloquently stated!
Thank you Fallen Angel!
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 7:49 PMIndeed! Thanks for that...
we are all creating burningman culture ...
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 10:22 AM
Bravo!! Very eloquently stated!
Thank you Fallen Angel!
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 11:15 PMIt's not so much a matter of having "lost" culture, as never having had one in the first place.
I am a native, fourth generation californian, of mixed European descent. Irish, english, german, italian, french, norwegian, swedish, spanish and dutch. And there's probably some more. This is common of many light-complected people in America, and especially in California.
I agree with you - people with strong cultural ties may not feel the need to go out and forge new traditions.
It's questionable to suggest, however, that culture and ethnicity come hand in hand, and that somewhere along the way white folk were dissociated from their native traditions or something like that. Some people simply do not have "native traditions." Or, they are surrounded by native traditions of other, neighboring groups and draw upon those in creating an amalgamated cultural identification.
In fact, you'll find many light-complected people in Califonia resent being called "white", and consider it a slur. Why? Because there's this assumption of default white culture, that white faces on television and in advertising resonate with us, somehow. Maybe they do in other parts of the country? But to assume that people of european descent identify with, say, Brittany Spears is not just inaccurate, it is insulting to our intelligence.
I grew up in the san fernando valley. Hablo espanol como todos en los angeles, and I'm a buddhist. Do I fit in with the mexicans on my block or the chinese kids I grew up with? Claro que no, pero their culture is still mine.
So what do kids like us do? We go to burning man, and make our own fun. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 12:11 AMUgh oh..
Watch out.......
Katharine is Irish, english, german, italian, french, norwegian, swedish, spanish, dutch, but most importantly a "native" californian"..........whatever that means.........
Here in San Francisco we have a phenomenon that goes something like this, the most pain in the arse, opinionated jerk at any party will inevitably proclaim themselves "native" to San Francisco. Similar to being in a pub in London with a Chelsea fan........
Who in this forum is listening to Britney Spears, and just in case someone was, did they immediately link poor Brit to all people of European descent..?
Free advice to follow:
A. If someone mutters the phrase "default white culture" you can safely assume that the conversation to follow is everybit inane as this particular thread. -
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 8:21 AM
I'm a native californian - because I was born here. The point the young lady above us was trying to make was, I believe, that "white" kids go to burning man because they have lost their native culture. I agree, but would add that I (and others like me) have not "lost" anything, but are representative of environment of amalgameted cultures - of which we are native.
People who have those "I'm from San Francisco" conversations (and I'm familiar with the type), are often trying to make some kind of point about their authenticity or knowledgablity relative to people not from San Francisco. My point is exactly the opposite - that people in the position of a "native californian" have no prior claim of authenticity on the cultures that may have influenced them. We may have grown up in mexican neighborhoods, but we'll never be mexican. You see. Which is what makes burning man so appealing.
So, Glen... do you have a point? Seems like your native SF buddies' consdecending BS is rubbing off on you.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 8:45 AMIt always amuses me when someone claims that the US doesn't have a culture of its own, when almost every little thing you do every day is a part of that culture but you just don't think of it that way.
www.zompist.com/amercult.html
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 11:14 AMShooter, points for style - way to toss chum into the waters. See the guppies rise to the surface, mouths gaping! Go, guppies, go! Fight the racism! -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 11:43 AMSee? Now that Freya, she's a troll. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 12:05 PMOh lord. You're kidding, right? I mean, if we look back at the original post, there are only two possibilities:
1) Shooter is fucking with people
2) Shooter is an idiot of such monumental proportions it doesn't justify any more conversation than "Gee, Shooter, you've got some underlying assumptions in your post that are pretty racist. Did you realize that not all people of color are poor? No? Well, there are probably cultural/social reasons that have more to do with racial distrubution at BM than cost. However, on the off chance that you're just fucking with us, I'm not going to get all in a big flutter over it."
Definitely not worth 111 posts. Riduculous.
With love,
Big Fat Troll -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 12:28 PM//Definitely not worth 111 posts. Riduculous. //
yah but the podcast was worth it! :) -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 12:53 PM*snicker*
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 1:52 PMWell this is deffinately an interesting issue , as a native New Yorker having grown up with a vast mix of Races & Cultures and even being Married to one of Latin and Asian Ethnicity and also having a pretty even mix of People from all walks of life in my Theme Camp this year I can only say that from what I have learned through speaking with other Friends that are Afro-American , Indian , Hispanic that it is not so much a matter of Finances but time and personal choice and when you consider that out of Millions of People that are living in this Country and abroad that only 40,000 + show up at this Event each year then the Numbers are quite low in comparison with greater Society .
What most of my Friends of color say when I talk to them about Burning Man is that Daaam Man I don't know how you could put up with all that Heat & Dust ! , cuz I sure could not ! and then I say well you just have to adjust and take certain safety measures and they say no thanks I will just stay right here in my Air Conditioned TV watching pad , so the point here is that it is very hard to get People out of their routine and to do something different in their lives and I know this because in Neighborhoods all over NYC for example you have People that choose to never leave "The Hood " and stay right where they are .
Society has molded alot of People to be around several objects and that is ... A TV , A Computer , Video Games , A Car , A Cell Phone , Etc , etc , etc , and to pull people away from some of that for a Week or longer is like squeezing water out of a rock .
Yes Burning Man is unique and there will always be a vast number of opinions regarding this event both positive and negative and in theory one cannot exist without the other , Yin / Yang but to say that only wealthy people are attending this event is only just another opinion in a sea of many , being of part Native American descent myself ( Arapaho ) and again growing up with many Races but also seeing many Races at Burning Man as in my Camp we had Afro - American , Asian , Indian , Hispanic , Caucasian , Etc one can only say that this was their choice to attend and was not a matter of Finances , not everyone is so Poor and therefor cannot go , Daily routine and Habits have alot of input here as well .
This is just my opinion on the subject and when Americans and others stop being Brain Washed and start to really mingle with each other then maybe we will all have a better understanding of how the World functions , how this will all unfold ? , only time will tell .
BTW Fallen Angel was one of my Camp Mates this year , thumbs up to you Bro ! .
Be Well All .... Vlad .
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 2:18 PMNext year we totally need a video game/tv camp. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 6:15 PMDance Dance Immolation comes close.
Actually now that I mention it, that's where I saw the most minorities all week, in the form of a gaggle of asian DDR nerds. And that's not racist, that's just the facts, anyone who can pull off Max 300 on heavy while wearing a heavy flame retardant suit is a DDR nerd.
-
-
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 3:07 PMhey, i cross dee fence...once or twice...ees no pro'lem for us mexicans to cross a stinking fence.
eef notting else, we cross dee fence to water dee duss down....since you got no lawn to cut.
---
adios amigo. -
-
Truth Revealed
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 5:28 PMI think I actually posted this thread last year, but it has inspired some interesting information and discussion. The point I would like you all to know is that last year, my girlfriend worked clean up for DPW, picking up all the shit you hippies left. And she commented, "Black Rock City: Largest Gated White Community in the US."
That's where the idea came from. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Truth Revealed
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 5:32 PMYour girlfriend was part of the corrupt bmorg? So she's to blame for the ruination of black rock city as you see it?
-
Re: Truth Revealed
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 6:05 PM//my girlfriend worked clean up for DPW, picking up all the shit you hippies left. And she commented, "Black Rock City: Largest Gated White Community in the US."//
of course she said that, DPW is fulla white people that dont hafta get real jobs. hahahaha!
or maybe i should say, how does she know, DPW doesnt hang out with burners!
i crack myself up.
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 6:04 PMYou know, talking to a bunch of White folks about why there's no/few POC at Burning Man... um, no offense, but seems a bit pointless.
Also, economics are probably not the biggest factor that keeps POC away from Burning Man. Fallen Angel made some excellent points as to what may discourage POC from coming to BM. I'd also add that the occasional fetishization of cultures/people discouraging, as well as the gross amounts of cultural appropriation that goes on in the community in general. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 6:08 PMLike those yarn dreadlocks that look so shitty? What the hell is wrong with people anyway? Hey Yarnhead you look like shit!
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 6:31 PMFA:
<<
The true culture of the fledgling U.S. was a society of mixed cultures, Dutch, English, etc., who had different ways, different languages, but a common goal (granted, slavery existed, but not all of the founding fathers truly believed that institution would last.) That has been lost to paranoia, exclusion, and finger pointing, and xenophobia.
>>
TESTIFY. Mm, mm, mm. That fired me up a little bit. Now let's remember to add
Native
African
Irish (they weren't considered 'white' per se, back then - didn't you know?)
and God's Chosen People: the Melungeons.
thanks -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 6:39 PMOkay, now I gotta ask. It's my understanding that the irish didn't really get here in large numbers until the 1840s (concurrent with the potato famine). Is that still "fledgeling" and connected with the founding fathers? So what time period are we talking here? And I bet the proper term is something more like Papist, when we talk about the Irish.
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Thu, September 20, 2007 - 11:03 PM"TESTIFY. Mm, mm, mm. That fired me up a little bit. Now let's remember to add
Native
African
Irish (they weren't considered 'white' per se, back then - didn't you know?)
and God's Chosen People: the Melungeons. "
Unfortunately, Natives weren't a part of American culture anymore than Mexicans living in Mexico are part of U.S. culture now. There were some influences, but they were still "over there." The Irish didn't come in large numbers until much later, as mentioned before, and were seen as lower than human, the same as the Italians, Jews, and Mexicans at certain points in history. Mexicans and Mexican-Americans are still at this point in history, but could digress into an Anglo/Hispanic animosity explanation that goes all the way back to Spain vs. England, which still permeates our American sensibilities today. This is going to sound harsh, but Africans were no more a part of American culture during the time of the founding, than farm equipment is a part of American culture today. They remained severely marginalized LEGALLY until the 1960's, whereas today they are still heavily marginalized socially, if not in-your-face legally. Their traditions were stripped (in much the same as Cherokee fashion) but portions remained, merged, and survived in some parts, such as the religious mix known as voodoo, which is a combination of African religious tradition, Catholicism, and probably some other influences (I'm no expert on voodoo.) As mentioned before, the government (yes, public education is run by government) tried to force out a culture of language (similar to the Cherokee situation) via violence on children within the school system, hence my father's resistance to speaking any Spanish to myself or siblings.
By the way, I've never heard of the Melungeons before. It's a fascinating read. Some of them are even part Portagee! My grandma would be proud. -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 4:50 PMEveryone in the U.S. should read "The Sneeches" by Dr. Seuss.
And I consider myself an Angry Black Man, though I laughing appear to be a Hebeish mom on the outside. I want reparations for slavery AND genocide. So far, bubkis. Frickin' red tape.
And I wasn't there. -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 4:50 PMlaughingLY
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 7:13 PMSpeaking of cultural appropriation... -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 7:23 PMI think this is my favorite thread. . .
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Fri, September 21, 2007 - 9:32 PMSorry for being so honest - It only hurts because it is so true! -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sat, September 22, 2007 - 5:38 PMWhile scrolling through and reading the post, I found myself getting a little bothered about what I was ‘perceiving’ was race and separation, again. But then as I journeyed through, and kept reading, I stopped and paused, and then it dawn on be: At least they are talking about race, and not trying to shoved the subject to one side. And then I went ‘WOW,’ this is cool, this is a beautiful thing; they are confronting the issue, and still learning.
Once I got out of my own way and limitations, I was able to see the bigger picture. Now with race and finances, I think it’s incorrect to assume that ‘Black’ people (or African-American, or Nubian, or whatever the new and transpiring identity clause will be), are any more or less insolvent (being in dept), or has less money then other racial identity.
‘Green Penis’ – “Colored Folks?” Are you by anyway related to Jim Crow? People, you run into that kind of passive aggressive psuedo talk in Seattle, but at the same time, realize that that is not Seattle. ‘MdjGutie,’ thank you for bringing some real solid intelligence with regards to the difference of ‘Colored People,’ and ‘People of Color.” “Tony’ thanks for keeping it real, and opening up some minds here.
Thanks ‘Shooter’ for getting the conversation going, and for opening up a subject that many would prefer you’d never questioned. But the threads speak for themselves, and it’s a clear indication that the question and/or comment did needed a voice behind it.
In regards to whose the minority (minor) and whose the majority (Major), I think Africans, Latinos, Asians, and other ethnic identities are the majority the World over, regardless of their conditions. Again, even in the wording ‘minority, its trick is to belittle one, while making the other ‘feel’ superior. All Psychology.
Peace,
Terry -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sat, September 22, 2007 - 11:01 PMOh, now you have to go and play the "race card". Until this thread, I didn't even have to think about what color my friends and campmates at Burning Man were, I just got to enjoy their wonderful personalities and zany senses of humour and giving natures.....but now you make me actually have to think about what color they are.....so there were a couple who were black, and three who were of hispanic descent and one from Portugal (Is that officially a person of color?) and me....I am officially 1/4 American Indian, since a Grandmother on one side was 1/4 Cherokee/Cheyenne and my Grandmother on the other side was 1/4 Assiniboine. Neither of them would have admitted they weren't full blooded "white" due to the predjudices of the day, and I don't think you would look at me and guess I wasn't either, but there you are. I read a statistic recently that 1 in 8 Americans have a black ancestor, whether or not it shows, so probably many of us are "people of color" whether we know it or not. Maybe even you ;-)
Just for the record, I saw a lot of mixed races/colors/skin tones until the dust storm thursday afternoon, and then we WERE all pretty white........! -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sat, September 22, 2007 - 11:21 PMLoveMinx
There are certainly times when a portuguese wasn't white. In the 18 and early 1900s white protestant was the norm from which catholic italians, irish and portuguese deviated. Of course, back then, it was a lot more apparent what church you went to because there was much less mobility and most people lived in small towns or on farms where people knew each other and kept track of things like that. I myself am fascinated by the idea that race is so fluid and that our definitions are so different from the previous generation's and that the next generation's with be different still. (Apparently, if you look at the census questions, every ten years the racial catagories are different.
You do mention one thing that I wonder about. It's very common to say that one is descended from a "Cherokee Princess." Well, the Cherokee don't even have princesses. Is it possible that this formula was an ancestral way of avoiding revealing that there was black ancestry in one's bloodline? I don't expect you to have an answer, nor am I challenging your understanding of your descent. I'm just curious as to social formulas and the information they do and don't reveal. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 12:34 AMI don't think I was descended from a Cherokee princess or anything....my great Grandfather's mother was from a Cheyenne tribe that was (forcibly) moved from the Montana/Dakota area in the 1800's to a Cherokee reservation in Oklahoma, and it was said her father wasn't Cheyenne. I think it's assumed he was of Cherokee descent, although he didn't stay with their tribe when they came back to Montana (and were stuck on another reservation). My Great Grandfather's Dad was Irish, recently "off the boat", so I suppose he was considered a person of color at that time as well.
Montana, where I'm from, is probably the "Largest gated white community" in the US. 700,000 people, and I would have to say that growing up I never saw a black person in any of the 6 communities I lived in. I also saw only 2 families of Asian descent (Doctors that were traveling through the Vetran's Administration and didn't stay long) and only 5 Hispanic families. Of course, none of them would be crazy enough to move to a place that is -50 degrees some days every winter (before the wind chill is factored in) or 115 degrees some days every summer. Only people of German, Nordic, Irish, Scottish or Welsh descent were hardy (or crazy) enough to live there.....
Isn't race (and religion) just an issue used by Governments to distract "the common" people so that they will spend a bunch of time infighting and as a result are much easier to control? Should we buy into that-or at least bring that disfunctional system of classifications to Burning Man? I think it would be nice to drop it, if people can bring themsleves to let go of a lifetime of (dysfunctional) conditioning.
There is research using DNA pointing to the fact that ALL of the people in the world (us) were descended from 6 different people. If their ancestors lived in Northern climates, they were largely light skinned due to the fact that their survival didn't depend on them developing melanin in order to protect themselves from the sun. If people lived in climates closer to the Equator, they would develop darker skin in order to survive skin problems caused by excessive sun exposure over the years. I'm sure in later years the amount of time spent outdoors also affected skin color (which is why wealthy Chinese Princesses have much lighter skin that their fieldworker neighbors)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_skin_color
Jesus was probably very dark skinned due to the fact that he lived in lands close to the equator. He was painted as light skinned by Italian artists using Northern Italian models which is probably why religious zealots try to portray him as white. He was also Jewish. I get very annoyed when people attack each other based on race or religious designations. So, "Us" vs. "Them"-what a detrimental viewpoint that most people in the world choose to take.
I think those are two big things dropping our society-and those all over the world. into a cesspool when we could have such a better society if we stuck to judging people on their measurable attributes. Those attributes are all I care about at Burning Man. Do people help others out, pull their weight, treat others fairly, create things, have grand ideas, make others feel good about themselves, give more than they take, contribute to the good of the whole, accept others with an open mind, try to make the world, or at least our little piece of it a better place?
OK, off my soapbox. It's just what came to mind when I saw this thread and then had to evaluate my campmates based on their color or "Potential" race ("wait, and didn't "S" and "A" have wierd, ethnic names? They looked "white" but where did they get those names? And didn't "I" like death rap music? Hmmmm, maybe that's why he had such a great tan")
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 1:52 PMHow very sad that this post actually made you think about what race you friends and campmates are. It's very unfortunate that you actually have to think about race and how it affects your Burning Man experience. But it's so nice that you can parade your friends of color around and show how diverse your groups of friends are. You can't be racist, you have Black friends, right? Oh, and you are descended from people who may have been of Native descent, so you really can't be racist!
< /sarcasm >
You know, when you are actually a person of color, race plays a part of your conceptions every day. Just because it doesn't affect you, doesn't mean that it doesn't affect all of us. There may not be burning crosses on the playa, but that doesn't mean that we don't have to deal with the "soft" racism of low expectations, or see our cultures bastardized by White people seeking "spirituality", or get fetishized for looking "exotic".
Also, the "race card"? Doesn't exist. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 9:35 AMForgive me, I forgot to insert the word </sarcasm> in my post since it seemed pretty self-evident to me.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 12:49 AMwait what? There were no black people at burning man? Hmmmm... I guess I forgot to pay attention. I don't see people for their color, I see people for their creativity, their humor, their spirit... -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 12:53 AM -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 1:00 AMLike too many Threads by this poser, sorry, poster...
The premise is inflammatory.
The purpose is to divide. Not build.
or...self promote.
Whatever.
KK -
-
Unsu...
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 9:14 AM"Like too many Threads by this poser, sorry, poster...
The premise is inflammatory.
The purpose is to divide. Not build.
or...self promote.
Whatever. "
This. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 2:07 PMThere is being color-blind, and there is purposeful ignorance of another's skin color, culture, and background to make ourselves feel better about not really knowing anything other than what we were raised with. Personally, I love to ask people about their ethnic backgrounds, because it does make for interesting conversation, and it widens your world just a bit more with each conversation.
I think it's better than assuming something about someone, no? Just because I run The Havana Room, and I'm a Latino, people ASSUME I must be Cuban. Wrong. However, it's a fair assumption because I'm light skinned, run a Cuban themed club at Burning Man, and I can dance. I'd rather talk to someone and share my varied family history (Mexican, Spanish, and Portuguese) and then have them share theirs, because in addition to creating fascinating conversation, you learn more about a person through their family history. While we are our own people, we are also shaped by our history.
A good friend of mine at BM was black. No big deal, right? Why bother to make a fuss about it? Because he's not just "black", he was born in Haiti, has an Italian grandfather (hence his last name), and spent much of his youth in New York. I got to know him better at BM, spent some quality time, and while discussing his background, had fascinating conversation and grew a bit closer to this friend. Another friend of mine is "white." Big deal, lots of white people at BM, right? Wrong. His story was unique and fascinating, such as how he is planning on changing his last name BACK to the old Prussian version of his last name, which was discarded by his grandfather when he came to the U.S. many years ago, in order to escape racism. I find this fascinating, and I love to hear how my friend is proud of his Prussian heritage, and is up on his family history.
What I don't understand is choosing to ignore someone's heritage, all for the facade of being "colorblind." Colorblind truly is colorblind, where you are not SEEING and knowing a wonderful and unique aspect of your friends.
Maybe I'm just biased, because in my culture, family history is very important, and your lineage is lovingly preserved.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 2:13 PMAnother white man trying to keep a brother down. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 25, 2007 - 6:35 PMShooter: " Another white man trying to keep a brother down."
That would be funny, except I'm not white. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 25, 2007 - 11:11 PMwhoops. damn demographics,
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Sun, September 23, 2007 - 3:52 PMLOL, hahahaha, Glenn, I came across that site a long time ago, and saw a Saturday Night Live kind of parody or satire that had me laughing.
Terry -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 9:08 AMhey guys,
racism is SO passe.
even here in england it (generally) is no big deal.
less than in USA i believe.
for goodness sake who cares about colour, heritage etc?
but then im a hippy...ha! -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 10:55 AMI don't see any particular systemic barriers to entry to BRC that are race-dependent. I think many people (of any race) who might really enjoy (and/or at least otherwise benefit from) the experience of Burning Man don't go for lack of information/knowledge about the event and/or from misinformation about the event and what it entails.
Sadly posts like this and some of the negativity in general that can be found on this site and in other public on-line forums probaly does little to allay the general misperceptions about Burning Man that exist out in the "real world."
Speaking from my own personal experience, my African American, French, Irish, Native American, German, English self has never felt anything but comfortable out on the Playa. Then again, my family lives in Boulder which is also predominantly white, liberal and arts-oriented. Thus, listening to the pigmentally challenged bemoan the lack of color around them is nothing new for me.
It's all good, even though the playa may have a long way to go before it can truly be considered a racially diverse environment, you can't tell me that its not a COLORFUL place.
Just my 2 cents, feel free to ignore my hot black ass if you feel so inclined.
J
Also, here is to more funk out there in 2008.
-
-
-
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 9:48 PMI would like to see more non-white people at the Burn **if** they want to go. But until I hear about groups of non-whites complaining that they cannot go and would like to go, I think you are pointing to a problem that does not exist.
It's funny that liberal white people feel like they have to have a quota of non-white friends. Kind of like this site:
www.blackpeopleloveus.com/ -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 9:51 PMWe could bus in African Americans from LA and Oakland on biodiesel hippie buses. Yeah, let's save the world. Must keep up the quotas in the fifth largest city in Nevada. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 11:49 PMand what about us Marronite-Pagan-Lithuanian Ex-Pats?
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Mon, September 24, 2007 - 11:56 PM"We could bus in African Americans from LA and Oakland on biodiesel hippie buses. Yeah, let's save the world. Must keep up the quotas in the fifth largest city in Nevada. "
Whoa. Only African Americans? What about hispanics, Shooter? Nevada is a Spanish word! Why can't we be in on the free transport? You think I want playa dust all over my car?
So wrong. -
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 25, 2007 - 10:09 AMWe have the Hispanics covered with Larry's American Dream, theme: tribes.tribe.net/run_for_the_border
But, if you don't want to run for the border, I suppose we can hook you up with the bus system.
-
-
Re: BRC: Largest Gated White Community in the US
Tue, September 25, 2007 - 12:46 PMWell, I was born here, so my fence jumping skills are, I'm sure, below par, but in the spirit of the theme, maybe being smuggled through the gate in someone's trunk would be more my speed, or I could use a fake I.D. to buy my ticket!
Wow, who woulda thought arrival could be such fun?
-
-
-
-