Advertisement
I'm coming in for the SF decomp, but are we allowed to bring glosticks to the event? I heard the LA decomp had "glowstick free zone" signs up everywhere
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sat, October 10, 2009 - 3:41 PMgo ahead and bring them if you like
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sat, October 10, 2009 - 5:48 PMThose sound like typical burny snark to me. I could be wrong. There seem to be a number of people who are anti-glow; they couch it in "green" terms. I'm just not sure that if you look at the whole life cycle of glow vs. blinkie that blinkies come out ahead. But what do I know? -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sat, October 10, 2009 - 6:25 PMGlo sticks are bulky and they fill landfills. Call it snarky but they're the least green of glowy options.
That said, they do have their uses and I do use them. Sparingly.
To my knowledge, only LA has instituted the "glo stick free" rule for Decom. -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sat, October 10, 2009 - 7:03 PMI've put down the glow sticks. Forever. Sworn off.
I found a glow-stick looking flashlight that is a single led that comes in red, green, and blue colors for a few bucks apiece. They get rid of the bulky glow sticks that are disposable, forever. I got 'em at Home Depot in the same section they sell flashlights.
And you can change the batteries in them.
-
-
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sun, October 11, 2009 - 12:20 AMGet some Flowtoys..
www.flowtoys.com
Sometimes I crack some sticks, my favorite are the Ultra Intensity (actually thats all I crack just because no LED can imitate that light). But for the most part LEDs are better for the environment and better for your wallet. If you want to go extreme green get some rechargeable batteries too, they save a lot of money and save a lot of landfills, every little bit helps. -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sun, October 11, 2009 - 10:07 AMAs you can see from the comments they are not very eco-friendly. Still lots of folks bring them and there is no ban on them at SF Decom. -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sun, October 11, 2009 - 8:33 PMI can't really see that from the comments, Bobzilla. I see a bunch of people s-a-y-i-n-g that they are, but the proof seems to be that "we say that they are better for the environment, therefore they are." I get the argument that glow takes up more room in landfill than battery operated lights--but, and this is a big one--battery operated lights, and batteries themselves, shouldn't be going into landfills anyway. And that stuff is made from heavy metals, I know mercury has almost, or maybe completely, been phased out, but I know that cadmium, for instance, is still used. And the acid in batteries means that a lot of them corrode and spread these toxins around. And a lot of batteries DO end up in landfills, and leach out later. I'm only just beginning to see battery collection boxes around, and I still have to make special trips, because they aren't all over the place. And if you use rechargeables, great, but it takes a LOT more energy to charge them than they then give out.
In short, it's hard to see the "glow bad" as anything but the typical narrow spectrum "green" thinking that I see all too much of all over the place. We have to think cradle to grave, from mining to landfill. I simply have not seen such an analysis of either technology, just sort of lazy knee-jerk reactions that couldn't get out of a wet paper bag if they tried. -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Mon, October 12, 2009 - 9:29 AMI hear you. I do recycle batteries at home and work. But I agree that many people don't. -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Mon, October 12, 2009 - 11:56 AMYou know the second year I went to the burn, I had a look at my mini-mag light and didn't work and was sort of fused solid. So I had to buy a new flashlight as well as new batteries. I think that if someone's going to the burn for the first time and doesn't know whether he or she will return, 2 or 3 dozen light sticks are better than a electronic gear that may never be used again.
But then I guess I have the view that electronics manufacture and disposal is a very dirty business. -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Mon, October 12, 2009 - 1:15 PMCrypto, the reason for your flashlight taking the nosedive into oblivion is the dust. Gypsum dust. I've seen it cause all kinds of havoc to vehicle electrical systems on-playa, and off as well. Exposed metal surfaces on batteries and electronics can be protected ( I use non-conductive silicone grease). Like I said - - -light sticks are not my choice.
Now, regarding your contention that electronics manufacture and disposal is a very dirty business - - - - and we're talking cradle to grave here - - - - - - - I'll agree up to a point. Whatever can be recycled is a good thing, and there are precious metals involved, particularly gold and silver....gold for the high-traffic electronic contacts and silver in the solder. Of course there's also copper, cadmium, germanium, gallium, and a few other metals and expensive commodities, too. Getting the electronics off the plastic is the hard part. And the plastic? Yep, nowadays, we've seen HDPE and PETE recycled. Metal cases contain iron (big deal)or aluminum.
If you want to be totally 'green', what are you doing on-playa in any case? -
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Mon, October 12, 2009 - 7:33 PMI know why my minimag died. The point I was making is that if I were a person who did that to her flashlight every year, it would be a very environmentally damaging--and avoidable--thing. So, if we're talking cradle to grave, the extra wasteful usage has to be included. I was really bad with tents, I think Scott and I bought a new one every year. When we left playa we were so fucking burnt that we didn't take care of it then, and it just sort of settled into something that never got done. Taking care of things takes energy. We have finite lives. We make choices--consciously or unconsciously--about how to deal with things. Sometimes we don't take the greenest route. I think the LA Decomp Organizers got a little prissy and self-righteous when they banned glows. You ban enough things because of the environmental cost, then you don't go to the burn. YOu don't turn on your computer. You just sit in a hole and wait to die. I believe in doing as little damage as possible. I also believe that past a certain point you don't get on other people's cases. Those poor schmucks who might have brought glow to la decomp are such a small part of the problem that it doesn't seem worth the time to go after them. I mean, whatever might have been saved, energy wise--if anything--has quite possibly been wiped out by keeping that thread on tribe's servers and by people reading it. It's back to my complaint about the complaints about Green Man. Focusing on one week, or one day, as opposed to the other 51 or 364 really doesn't give you much leverage in actual change.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Sun, October 11, 2009 - 11:49 AMactually, there are some glow poi out there that are bright on the comparable level to high intensity glowsticks:
www.superbrighttoys.com/superb...me.html
Made by a really good cat, Brad Dervish, from New Hampshire. By far the brightest poi out there.
-
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Mon, October 12, 2009 - 9:34 AMjust more junk from china to throw away once they're dead.
they also most likely contain BPA, which is not good.
or....if you can figure out how to reuse them once dead, then bring'm.
art project?
anal probes?
-
Re: glo sticks at SF decomp?
Mon, October 12, 2009 - 4:42 PMCrypto:
Glow sticks are intended for one use only, and also they are made from plastic, which is derived from petro-chemicals and is energy intensive to create. If that is not enough the chemicals inside of them produce a bi product called phenol, which is also known as carbolic acid, which is in fact toxic for you. A little history about this chemical it was used before and up until the Second World War by Nazis via injection for quick executions because it was easily produced and efficient in that manner. Phenol is toxic, corrosive and has been deemed a class 3 mutagen. Keep in mind this is all backed by scientific evidence and none of this is just because I say it is. Millions of these glow sticks are sold, cracked and thrown away annually, I don't know about you but I would consider that harmful for the environment..